Skip to main content
CLEC Investment & WealthCLEC Investment & Wealth
  1. Home
  2. Global ETF Comparison
CLEC Investment & WealthCLEC Investment & Wealth

CLEC content, long-term investing tools, and source materials for learning and independent review.

X (Twitter)Apple Podcasts
Tools
  • Start Here
  • Related
  • Investing Tools
  • Nasdaq-100 DCA Calculator
  • Asset Allocation Simulator
  • Global ETF Comparison
  • Global Nasdaq & S&P ETF Map
  • Mainland China U.S. Index QDII Comparison
  • QQQ returns by year
  • SPY returns by year
Resources
  • Blog
  • Documentation
  • Video
  • The CLEC Handbook
  • Database
About
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Waitlist
  • Changelog
  • Roadmap
Legal
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Disclaimer
  • Anti-Fraud Notice
© 2026 CLEC Investment & Wealth. All rights reserved.·Sitemap

Investing Tool

Global ETF Comparison

Nasdaq, S&P, China A-shares, Taiwan, world and semiconductors — 21 broad / core indices on one common basis, compared for long-term return, risk and valuation, each with a representative ETF.

Levels through the common completed session of 15 Oct 2026; valuations dated separately

OverviewRisk vs ReturnYearly HeatmapValuationDrawdownVerdicts

All Instruments

21 global broad indices at a glance (total-return CAGR, dividends reinvested; with a representative ETF)

InstrumentETFMarketSinceTR CAGRPrice CAGRMax DDRecoveryPEYield
Nasdaq-100NDXQQQUS198513.9%12.2%-82.9%15y34.5—
S&P 500SPXVOOUS195710.5%7.7%-56.8%5y24.81.1%
Russell 1000RUIIWBUS198611.3%9.2%-53.0%4y24.51.1%
Russell 1000 GrowthRLGIWFUS198611.0%9.7%-68.0%15y31.00.5%
Dow Jones Industrial AverageDJIADIAUS18969.7%5.6%-89.0%22y21.71.5%
FTSE 100UKXISF.LUK19847.8%5.7%-52.6%12y—3.1%
Nikkei 225N2251321.TJapan1949—8.0%-81.9%34y21.61.5%
KOSPIKS11EWYSouth Korea198010.6%9.4%-75.5%11y——
Hang Seng IndexHSI2800.HKHong Kong196411.6%9.2%-91.5%7y13.83.0%
Hang Seng TECHHSTECH3067.HKHong Kong2014—2.3%-75.3%Under water28.21.1%
CSI 300000300510300.SSChina A-share20059.4%7.0%-72.8%13y12.9—
CSI A500000510512050.SSChina A-share20048.7%7.8%-70.0%13y14.3—
SSE STAR 50000688588000.SSSTAR Market20197.9%6.6%-63.2%4y63.3—
Gold SpotXAUCommodityGLDCommodity1971—9.1%-70.0%28y——
Silver SpotXAGCommoditySLVCommodity1971—6.8%-93.0%46y——
US Total MarketVTIVTIUS20019.5%7.8%-55.5%4y26.9—
FTSE Global All CapVTVTGlobal20088.6%6.6%-50.3%3y22.8—
MSCI US Info TechVGTSectorVGTUS200414.9%14.2%-54.6%3y36.2—
TWSE Taiwan 5000500050Taiwan200314.7%11.6%-55.8%2y28.21.2%
PHLX Semiconductor (SOX)SOXSectorSOXQUS1993—15.8%-85.0%17y51.9—
TAIEXTAIEX006204Taiwan1966—10.9%-80.4%31y——
Strongest long-term

Nasdaq-100 / US tech / semiconductors lead on long-term CAGR — but are the priciest and most concentrated.

Cheapest

China A-shares (CSI 300 / A500), UK FTSE and Hang Seng: low PE, high yield, best value.

Most volatile

Semiconductors, Hang Seng Tech, STAR 50 and silver swing hardest — the highest upside tests your discipline most.

Risk vs Return

No free lunch — high returns usually come with deep drawdowns

Top-left wins

High return + shallow drawdown = best value: S&P 500, Russell 1000, VTI cluster here.

Top-right, high-beta

Nasdaq / tech / semis return the most, but fall the hardest — only yours if you can hold.

Bottom-right, beware

Deep drawdowns without the CAGR to show for it (silver, some EM) — the worst trade-off.

Yearly Return Heatmap

The bull/bear rhythm at a glance (total return %, green up / red down)

Instrument \ Year0910111213141516171819202122232425
Nasdaq-100+55+20+4+18+37+19+10+7+330+40+49+28-32+55+26+21
S&P 500+27+15+2+16+32+14+1+12+22-4+32+18+29-18+26+25+18
Russell 1000+28+16+1+17+33+13+1+12+22-5+31+21+26-19+26+25+17
Russell 1000 Growth+37+17+3+15+34+13+6+7+30-1+36+39+28-29+43+33+19
Dow Jones Industrial Average+23+14+8+10+30+100+17+28-3+25+10+21-7+16+15+15
FTSE 100+27+13-2+10+19+1-1+19+12-9+17-11+18+5+8+10+25
Nikkei 225+19-3-17+23+57+7+90+19-12+18+16+5-9+28+19+26
KOSPI+50+22-11+9+1-5+2+3+22-17+8+31+4-25+19-10+76
Hang Seng Index+56+8-17+27+7+6-4+4+41-10+130-12-13-10+22+32
Hang Seng TECH-32-27-8+19+24
CSI 300+97-12-25+8-8+52+6-11+22-25+36+27-5-20-9+18+20
CSI A500-9+18-25+36+31+1-23-7+15+25
SSE STAR 50+39+1-31-11+16+36
Gold Spot+25+30+10+7-28-2-10+9+13-1+18+25-60+14+27+67
Silver Spot+49+83-10+9-36-19-12+15+6-9+15+48-13+30+22+149
US Total Market+29+17+1+16+34+130+13+21-5+31+21+26-19+26+24+17
FTSE Global All Cap+33+13-7+17+23+4-2+9+24-10+27+17+18-18+22+16+22
MSCI US Info Tech+62+13+1+14+31+18+5+14+37+3+49+46+31-30+53+29+22
TWSE Taiwan 50+75+13-16+12+12+17-6+20+18-5+34+31+22-21+27+49+37
PHLX Semiconductor (SOX)+70+13-12+6+40+28-3+37+38-8+60+51+41-35+67+20+43
TAIEX+82+14-17+13+15+12-6+15+19-4+27+26+27-17+30+31+28
No perennial winner

When US stocks soar, A-shares can slump and vice versa — cross-region diversification smooths any single market's boom-bust years.

More green than red

Over time, most broad indices have far more up years than down — the very reason holding long pays off.

Valuation Cross-Section

Valuation dates range from 30 Jun to 16 Oct 2026; see each note; missing values are blank

P/E (lower is cheaper)

CSI 300
12.9
Hang Seng Index
13.8
CSI A500
14.3
Nikkei 225
21.6
Dow Jones Industrial Average
21.7
FTSE Global All Cap
22.8
Russell 1000
24.5
S&P 500
24.8
US Total Market
26.9
TWSE Taiwan 50
28.2
Hang Seng TECH
28.2
Russell 1000 Growth
31.0
Nasdaq-100
34.5
MSCI US Info Tech
36.2
PHLX Semiconductor (SOX)
51.9
SSE STAR 50
63.3

Dividend yield (higher cash return)

FTSE 100
3.1%
Hang Seng Index
3.0%
Dow Jones Industrial Average
1.5%
Nikkei 225
1.5%
TWSE Taiwan 50
1.2%
S&P 500
1.1%
Russell 1000
1.1%
Hang Seng TECH
1.1%
Russell 1000 Growth
0.5%
Valuation is gravity on long-term returns

Buying cheap (low PE, high yield) is your margin of safety; expensive assets borrow from the future, and long-run returns usually get compressed.

Drawdown & Recovery

How deep, how long — max drawdown and time to recover

Historical max drawdown (shallower is sturdier)

Silver Spot
-93.0%
Hang Seng Index
-91.5%
Dow Jones Industrial Average
-89.0%
PHLX Semiconductor (SOX)
-85.0%
Nasdaq-100
-82.9%
Nikkei 225
-81.9%
TAIEX
-80.4%
KOSPI
-75.5%
Hang Seng TECH
-75.3%
CSI 300
-72.8%
CSI A500
-70.0%
Gold Spot
-70.0%
Russell 1000 Growth
-68.0%
SSE STAR 50
-63.2%
S&P 500
-56.8%
TWSE Taiwan 50
-55.8%
US Total Market
-55.5%
MSCI US Info Tech
-54.6%
Russell 1000
-53.0%
FTSE 100
-52.6%
FTSE Global All Cap
-50.3%

Time from peak to full recovery (years)

Hang Seng TECH
Under water
Silver Spot
45.8y
Nikkei 225
34.2y
TAIEX
30.8y
Gold Spot
28.0y
Dow Jones Industrial Average
22.3y
PHLX Semiconductor (SOX)
17.3y
Russell 1000 Growth
15.2y
Nasdaq-100
15.1y
CSI 300
13.3y
CSI A500
13.3y
FTSE 100
11.9y
KOSPI
10.8y
Hang Seng Index
6.6y
S&P 500
5.4y
US Total Market
4.4y
Russell 1000
4.0y
SSE STAR 50
3.8y
MSCI US Info Tech
3.3y
FTSE Global All Cap
2.6y
TWSE Taiwan 50
2.2y
Drawdown is the real test of holding long

Nasdaq once fell 83% and took 15 years to recover; Hang Seng Tech, STAR 50 and A-shares were all halved. Whether you refuse to sell at the darkest hour decides textbook gains vs. losses.

One-line Verdicts

Each instrument, one line on what it is and whether it's worth it

InstrumentTagOne-line take
Nasdaq-100NDXGrowth KingLarge non-financial growth stocks with substantial technology concentration and drawdown risk.
S&P 500SPXEquity BenchmarkA capitalization-weighted US large-cap benchmark spanning sectors, with exposure to concentration in its largest companies.
Russell 1000RUITotal MarketA broad US large- and mid-cap index with wider coverage than the S&P 500, while capitalization weighting retains large-company concentration.
Russell 1000 GrowthRLGPure GrowthThe growth segment of the Russell 1000; growth expectations and technology concentration amplify valuation and cycle risks.
Dow Jones Industrial AverageDJIABlue-chip VeteranA 130-year-old blue-chip aristocrat whose price-weighting is a statistical relic, but its 30 hand-picked cash cows survived the Great Depression — it rises less than the Nasdaq and falls more gently too.
FTSE 100UKXValue & YieldAn index of large UK-listed companies across sectors; international revenues and sterling movements also affect returns.
Nikkei 225N225Longest BearJapan’s price-weighted blue-chip index; higher-priced stocks have greater influence and currency moves affect foreign-investor returns.
KOSPIKS11AI LeverageKorea’s composite equity index has significant electronics and semiconductor exposure, alongside industry-cycle and currency risks.
Hang Seng IndexHSIFlagship Blue-chipHong Kong’s flagship blue-chip index spans financials and technology; distinguish dividends from price returns and consider historical drawdowns.
Hang Seng TECHHSTECHHigh-beta China TechHong Kong's Nasdaq, but wilder — the regulatory crackdown smashed it from 10,000 to 2,700 (down 75%) and it still hasn't reclaimed its high; a high-beta tool for betting on a China-tech turnaround, not a ballast.
CSI 300000300China Blue ChipsA broad index of large Shanghai and Shenzhen stocks; distinguish price returns from dividend-inclusive total returns.
CSI A500000510Core BroadAn A-share benchmark emphasizing industry coverage; long-term history before launch includes backtests rather than live fund returns.
SSE STAR 50000688Hard TechA representative STAR Market technology index with concentrated sector exposure and valuation volatility; a high P/E does not ensure strong returns.
Gold SpotXAUCommoditySafe HavenA precious metal without cash flows, influenced by real rates, the dollar and demand; defensive use does not eliminate drawdowns.
Silver SpotXAGCommodityHigh-Beta MetalCombines industrial and precious-metal demand with substantial volatility; it pays no dividend and equity valuation ratios do not apply.
US Total MarketVTIAll USBroad US large-, mid- and small-cap exposure, shown using VTI prices. The CRSP benchmark has been renamed Morningstar; capitalization concentration remains relevant.
FTSE Global All CapVTAll WorldGlobal developed- and emerging-market equities, shown using VT prices; diversification still carries capitalization and currency risks.
MSCI US Info TechVGTSectorUS TechUS information technology exposure, shown using VGT prices; sector concentration differs from broad-market diversification.
TWSE Taiwan 500050Taiwan Blue ChipsTaiwan large-cap exposure, shown using 0050 prices and a split-adjusted historical base; semiconductor concentration matters.
PHLX Semiconductor (SOX)SOXSectorCompute CycleA semiconductor-sector index exposed to technology and capital-spending cycles, with concentrated holdings and a history of deep drawdowns.
TAIEXTAIEXTaiwan MarketTaiwan’s broad listed-equity index; capitalization weighting gives large technology companies substantial influence.
No best index — only the one that fits you

US stocks are strongest but dearest, A/UK/HK shares cheapest, Japan & Korea are AI-cycle high-beta, gold & silver are hedges. Know what each earns and what risk it carries, then allocate to your own risk tolerance.

All 21 levels use the common completed session of 2026-10-15. Price indices exclude dividends; representative ETF prices and historical total-return estimates retain their existing bases. Long-run growth and CAGR were recalculated from fixed historical bases and remain model estimates. Taiwan 50’s split-adjusted base, full-year returns and historical drawdowns were not fully reverified; 2026 is incomplete. Separate valuation dates: CSI/Nikkei 16 Oct; SPY/DIA 14–15 Oct; FTSE Russell, Hang Seng and Yuanta 0050 30 Sep; available Invesco/Vanguard factsheets still 30 Jun.

Original sources: Yahoo Finance price-index and representative ETF daily bars, CSI official data, Eastmoney HSTECH historical close, TWSE 0050 and LBMA gold PM/silver fixes. Valuations use original SSGA, Nikkei, CSI, FTSE Russell, Hang Seng, Yuanta, Invesco and Vanguard pages/factsheets. Unverified KRX/TAIEX valuations remain blank. See the 2026-10-16 audit for field evidence and historical-model limits.

Past performance does not indicate future results. This page is educational, not investment advice.